So, D totally helped me solve a lifelong question last night.
When I was in school, I had to read The Phantom Tollbooth by Norton Juster. In it, there's a point where the main character passes through a market in Dictionopolis where letters are sold after being grown in orchards, and descriptions of a few of the letters' tastes soon follow.
I read Tollbooth when I was about twelve, and ever since I've wondered what all the letters would taste like. Lying in bed last night reading, I explained the question to D, who promptly opened a lively discussion with me about the issue.
Me: Q is so not cardamom. You totally pulled that out of your ass.
...
D: Q is totally garlic because it never goes out on its own and is better with other things. And when you use it on its own it's totally garish.
...
D: See, G is totally banana-- it goes with H (wheat bread) and U (honey), and if you spell dough it totally makes a peanut butter and banana sandwich!
Me: But O is mayonnaise...
Together: Eeeew.
Me: And yet, Elvis would probably approve.
So here's the list we came up with:
- A: cucumber (crispy and yet somewhat nondescript but with a nice flavor)
- B: peach (juicy-- I admit, this one got thrown here because peach had to be in it somewhere)
- C: apple
- D: peanut butter (it always sort of hangs in the roof of my mouth)
- E: butter cookie (crispy and goes with everything, but can be soft and a good complement)
- F: marshmallow
- G: banana
- H: wheat bread (a soft complement to other letters: filler with decent stand-on your own vagueness: think beige, peeps.)
- I: pineapple
- J: celery
- K: lettuce (crispy with lots of crunch, but not a lot of independent taste)
- L: water with lemon (fluid and liquid, but not quite flavorless)
- M: filet mignon
- N: cream cheese
- O: mayonnaise (a little or a lot, it's good with other things but a little senseless on its own)
- P: sugar snap peas
- Q: garlic (stated above)
- R: strawberries
- S: soda water (good to dilute the more serious stuff down, makes a good combination with pretty much everything else)
- T: chicken (it's sort of the baseline for everything)
- U: honey
- V: onion
- W: orange jello
- X: sawdust (of course)
- Y: tomato
- Z: Pop Rocks (obviously.)

Comments (4)
I would have to say this post is very "A" which in addition to cucumbers, also indicates "Awesome."
Posted by Sister Sassy | September 14, 2008 11:16 PM
Posted on September 14, 2008 23:16
I love this. It's totally the type of conversation we'd have!
Posted by :: jozjozjoz :: | September 15, 2008 2:12 AM
Posted on September 15, 2008 02:12
D used "garish" in a sentence? I never would have guessed...
Posted by Steven | September 15, 2008 12:28 PM
Posted on September 15, 2008 12:28
What, do you guys have synesthesia? (Look it up on wikipedia...)
I'm surprised how much I agree with your matches, though - you wouldn't think this would be very universal. I would have gone with lemon for 'E' because it's a very fresh letter.
Sometime we can talk about how I prefer even numbers to odd because they feel so much smoother in my mind.
Nice post!
Posted by Addie | September 19, 2008 12:31 AM
Posted on September 19, 2008 00:31